Was Greek Mythology’s King Agamemnon Real?

Mycenaean death masks
Mycenaean death masks. The one on the right is the so-called “Mask of Agamemnon”. Credit: Zde / CC BY-SA 3.0 / Xuan Che / CC BY 2.0 / Wikimedia Commons

King Agamemnon is one of the most famous and significant characters of Greek mythology. He was the leader of the Greek forces that attacked the city of Troy during the Trojan War. But was Agamemnon real, or was he merely a figure of mythology with no specific real-life basis?

Who was Agamemnon?

First of all, let us clarify who Agamemnon was supposed to have been. He first appears in Homer’s Iliad, written in the mid-seventh century BCE. After that, he appears in many subsequent tales and records about the Trojan War. He is, after all, one of the central characters in the legend of the war between the Greeks and Trojans.

He was the older brother of Menelaus, the king whose wife, Helen, ran away with (or was taken by) Paris of Troy. Menelaus was the king of Sparta, while Agamemnon was the king of Argos, with a center at Mycenae. The Greek leaders worked together to besiege the city of Troy to get Helen back, and Agamemnon led this grand alliance.

This is how Agamemnon is presented in legends. However, is there any reason to believe that he may have been a real person?

Real figures from Homer’s own era

There is reason to believe that many characters mentioned in Homer’s poems are people who either lived in Homer’s own time or not too long prior to it. Some ancient records about Homer’s life make it quite clear that he placed several of his contemporaries in the Iliad and the Odyssey.

For example, Pseudo-Herodotus’ Life of Homer and Pseudo-Plutarch’s similar text explain that Homer’s mother married a music teacher named Phemius. Meanwhile, a poet named Phemius appears in the Odyssey. Pseudo-Herodotus’ Life of Homer also mentions a leather shoemaker named Tychius as a contemporary of young Homer. In the Iliad, we find that Homer referenced a leatherworker named Tychius.

Legends about King Midas definitely describe a historical figure who lived in or near Homer’s time. Since Midas allegedly lived at about the time of the Trojan War, this is direct proof that at least some of the legendary figures from that part of Greek mythology were actual people who lived as approximate contemporaries of Homer.

The real King Agamemnon

With this in mind, could Agamemnon also have been a real person from Homer’s own time? It is certainly worth looking to see if there is someone who would fit the profile. As it so happens, there is a very clear reference to a real Agamemnon from that era of history.

There are historical Greek records that mention a real ‘King Agamemnon of Cyme.’ Cyme was a Greek city in the northwest corner of Anatolia. It was ‘the largest and best of the Aeolian cities,’ that is, the cities of northwest Anatolia, according to Strabo. Hence, the real King Agamemnon of Cyme must logically have been a powerful king. This fits in well with the Agamemnon of Homer’s Iliad.

Furthermore, when did this real Agamemnon live? His daughter married the historical King Midas, the late-eighth century BCE king of Phrygia. Therefore, this Agamemnon must have been an older contemporary of Homer.

Painting of Midas Accidentally Turning His Daughter to Gold
Midas’ Daughter Turned to Gold, 1893. Credit: Walter Crane, Public Domain

Was the king of Cyme the real Agamemnon?

Why do we believe that the Agamemnon of Homer’s Iliad may have stemmed directly from the real Agamemnon of Cyme? For one thing, he was the father-in-law of King Midas. We know for a fact that King Midas was brought into the Greek legends around the era of the Trojan War. Therefore, it would not be surprising if someone closely connected to him, such as his father-in-law Agamemnon of Cyme, was likewise brought into the Greek legends of that time period.

Additionally, Agamemnon of Cyme’s status must have seemed immense to Homer. Most ancient writers agreed that Homer came from somewhere in western Anatolia, although no one could agree on the specific city he was from. Some writers even claimed he was from Cyme in particular. Regardless of where exactly his hometown was located, he was almost certainly from that general region.

Since Cyme was the most prominent city of northwest Anatolia, Agamemnon must have likewise been a prominent king. The fact that his daughter married King Midas, the incredibly rich king who ruled over the powerful Phrygian kingdom, further attests to Agamemnon’s importance.

Therefore, to Homer, Agamemnon of Cyme was not the mere footnote in history that he appears to be now. He must have seemed very much like the kind of powerful Greek leader that Homer described in the Iliad.

Supporting evidence

In addition to the intuitive logic of this identification, there is even more explicit evidence in support of it. According to Strabo, the dynasty that ruled over Cyme claimed descent from Agamemnon. This is in reference to the Agamemnon of legend from Homer’s Iliad. This appears to be strong evidence that the historical Agamemnon of Cyme was understood to be the real Agamemnon from the legend rather than merely a namesake.

Even more supporting evidence comes from the chronology of the Trojan War. Many people take for granted that the Trojan War occurred in the Bronze Age. However, some scholars have argued that it happened later. Nikos Kokkinos, for example, revealed in depth how the popular ancient date for the Trojan War actually came from miscalculations. An investigation into some of the earliest evidence about the Trojan War points to a much more recent date.

Therefore, it may well be that Homer did not take the real Agamemnon of Cyme and transport him into the distant past for his Iliad. It could easily be that Homer actually had the fairly recent past in mind when he wrote the Iliad. The overall world presented in the Iliad is consistent with this view.

Because of this, it may well be that Homer was explicitly talking about Agamemnon of Cyme when he wrote about a king by that name in his poem.

New Femicide Shocks Greece: Woman Murdered by Her Ex

woman killed in Greece outside police station
A 28-year-old woman was murdered as she sought help from the police. Credit: Greek Reporter

In another case of femicide in Greece, a 28-year-old woman was fatally stabbed on Monday evening shortly after she had gone to her local police station in Agioi Anargyroi in northern Athens to seek police protection against her ex-boyfriend.

Investigators have established that her 39-year-old ex-boyfriend, who is presently hospitalized after hurting himself with the same knife he used to murder the young woman, repeatedly stabbed her.

The 28-year-old reportedly saw her ex-boyfriend hanging around outside her home on Monday night and decided to call the cops for assistance. It seems that the attacker followed her there, stood outside waiting, and attacked her just a short distance away.

An internal police inquiry was launched on Tuesday. The actions of the officers at the police station where she filed the complaint are being investigated, with some reports suggesting the young woman had asked for protection on her way back home but was told there were no police cars available to escort her.

The same reports also suggest she was calling the 100 emergency number to ask for an escort when she was attacked. The 28-year-old had filed a lawsuit against the 39-year-old after they broke up in 2020, accusing him of abuse and rape. She was granted a restraining order on the grounds of that suit that ostensibly prohibited him from coming near her.

Rise in femicide crime shocks Greece

In the past few years, there has been a rise in femicide crime in Greece.

The high-profile case of Caroline Crouch in 2021 brought the issue of femicide to national attention. This case also highlighted how societal views can be problematic with the defense attempting to justify the crime.

The crime was unique, as rates of violent crime are comparatively low in Greece. The revelation of a marriage to a seemingly nice guy who is actually a monster that murdered his spouse has shaken the cultural cornerstone of “a loving Greek family with a devoted husband and father.”

There are ongoing efforts to address the issue. Activists are pushing for femicide to be recognized as a separate crime with harsher punishments, and there are calls for improved support systems for victims of domestic violence.

In 2022, Greece put the panic button, a digital application that will instantly help you reach out for help if you find yourself in a difficult situation, into effect.

The panic button sends a short text message to the police in instances in which family violence is associated with a threat or danger to life and physical integrity. The purpose is immediate intervention by the police force.

In short, there will be a three-digit number that you call with your mobile phone and then immediately click on the ‘panic’ indicator that comes out on the screen.

Those eligible for registration during the pilot operation of the program include women who are victims of domestic violence. Particularly, this refers to female victims living in the region of Attica and regional unit of Thessaloniki.

The Teacher of Arcadia: Rethinking the Story of Modern Greece

0
Ruins of the Temple of Olympian Zeus with the Acropolis in the background, under a clear blue sky.
The majestic remnants of the Temple of Olympian Zeus, with a view of Athens’ iconic Acropolis in the distance. Credit: Jean-Pierre Dalbéra, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

The novel by Greek cinematographer Thodoros Maragos titled “The Teacher of Arcadia and the TALOS 21st Century,” is a riveting and timely book that has the power to inspire and change your life, help you rethink the conventional story of modern Greece.

By Evaggelos Vallianatos

My artist friend Evi Sarantea from the island of Euboea introduced me to the Greek cinematographer Thodoros Maragos. I watched several of his documentaries. They are political and philosophical. They are commentaries on the history and politics of the 200-year-old modern Greek state and society.

They zero in on foreign influence, which shaped the politics and economics of Greece. The tragedy of this country in the third decade of the twenty-first century, tied to foreign debt and perpetual humiliation, is that it is the same country that, in the classical age of some 3,000 to 2,500 years ago and in the Alexandrian Era, 2,300 to 2,000 years ago, gave us the rule of law, democracy, philosophy, the Parthenon, beautiful arts, architecture, theater, the Olympics, Aristotle, science, Alexander the Great, advanced technology of the Antikythera computer of genius, and civilization.

How did that happen? I have tried to answer this question in my articles and books. But the films and documentaries of Maragos, many of them award-winning, give us a unique Greek perspective from the ground up of how modern Greece faced the crises and tragedies of the twentieth century.

Maragos is not exactly optimistic about resolving the dramatic debt impoverishment the European Union, the European Central Bank, and America’s International Monetary Fund perversely saddled on the country. He says this tragedy will last for a long time. He accuses Germany, Britain, and America for many of the misfortunes of tyrannizing the Greek people.

Like forcing corrupt Greek politicians to de-industrialize the country, making it dependent on imports and ceaseless borrowing – for their personal profit and the profit of their foreign sponsors.

The Teacher of Arcadia

Teacher of Arcadia

Maragos summarized his vision for Greece in his 2023 Greek book, The Teacher of Arcadia and the TALOS 21st Century. I read the book and loved it. Though it is a novel, the book is a story that unites ancient and modern Greece, and how a teacher in a mountain village of Arcadia, Pege (water hall), Istros Aetovouneas, acts like Socrates by teaching virtue.

He teaches all, children, and adults. His mission is to help the inhabitants of Pege think like their ancient ancestors, embracing reason rather than superstition. Cultivate the land, he urges them, for self-reliance in food; reject the war gifts of unethical modern technology like those of Artificial Intelligence pretending to win the war against death, promising long lives and immortality to those with lots of money.

Istros reminds us that god Hephaistos created TALOS, a flying anthropomorphic robot in the second millennium BCE in Minoan Crete. That version of AI was useful, he says, because it protected Crete and Europa, the beautiful lover of Zeus. But now, he says, things are upside down.

He says to the peddlers of AI that love is not mathematics and that AI without feelings is pure destruction. I agree with him. AI is a dragon the billionaires created to control us, the planet, and its wealth. They care less that this factory technology may become another version of nuclear bombs. My alternative and that of Maragos is a Renaissance in modern Greece, so that the wisdom and freedom of the ancients will, once again, take deep roots in the soil of Arcadia and Greece.

The Teacher of Arcadia is a riveting and timely book that has the power to inspire and change your life, help you rethink the conventional story of modern Greece. The dream, of course, is all about turning this modern Greece into a country, which is as close as possible to Hellas. Reading this thoughtful book one understands the life and death struggle of the evolving Greek tragedy of the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, itself the product of incompetent and almost traitorous Greek leadership and overwhelming foreign influence.

The dream of Kapodistrias of a sacred Hellas

The Greek Revolution of 1821 and the first President of Greece Ioannes Kapodistrias sowed the seeds of freedom and the return to Hellenic culture in the emerging Hellenic polis.

Indeed, in 1816, Kapodistrias dreamed of a Hellas in Greece, a country guaranteed by all states to be inviolable, independent, and sacred in order to advance the sciences and enlightenment for humanity.

But his assassination on September 27, 1831 by Greeks very possibly funded by Britain reversed the course of Greek Renaissance and history.

The Europeans imported a German king for the new “independent” country, which then started growing up in the shadow of the Turkish enemy and unfriendly Europe and America.

Maragos’ book and his films and documentaries, however, include a glimmer of hope that the Greeks, finally, are beginning the arduous road home.

Evaggelos Vallianatos is a historian and environmental theorist. He earned his Ph.D. in history at the University of Wisconsin and did his postdoctoral studies in the history of science at Harvard. He worked on Capitol Hill, the US Environmental Protection Agency, and taught at several universities. He authored hundreds of articles and seven books, including The Antikythera Mechanism: The Story Behind the Genius of the Greek Computer and its Demise.

Thessaloniki Metro Station Set to Open After Two-Decade Wait

0
Metro Station in Thessaloniki set to open in November.
The metro station in Thessaloniki is set to open this November. Credit: Patrickios. CC BY-4.0/Wikimedia Commons/Patrickios

A long-awaited metro station may finally be opening in Thessaloniki at the end of November. This will put an end to a nearly two-decade wait which will alleviate some of the heavy road traffic in Greece’s second most crowded city.

After a wait of nearly two decades, the metro’s opening means around 15 percent of the northern port city’s commuters will be able to begin using the system. It is likely this will draw in some of the bus users and those who currently walk, as posited by Apostolos Papagiannakis, an associate professor in network and transport planning at the Aristotle University of Thessaloniki.

In November last year, hundreds of visitors flocked to see the interior of the Agia Sofia metro station in Thessaloniki during an “open house” event.

At that time, there was no set date for the metro system’s opening, but it was among 71 public and private spaces of architectural interest that opened for the day as part of the 2023 “open house” tour event.

Among the visitors was Christos Staikouras, the Greek Minister of Infrastructure and Transport, who promised the crowd that Thessaloniki would have a working metro system before the end of 2024.

The long-delayed Thessaloniki metro project

Residents of Thessaloniki have anticipated the completion and operation of the metro system in the city for many years, as heavy road traffic is a persistent issue in the daily life of Greece’s second most crowded city.

The 3.5-billion-euro project was originally expected to open to the public by 2012. Construction began almost two decades ago in 2006, but progress was delayed due to a series of important archaeological discoveries in the metro tunnels.

When completed, the Thessaloniki metro system will extend 9.6 kilometers (six miles) and serve 13 stations.

“Our commitment remains unchanged. Thessaloniki will have an operational metro in the second half of 2024,” said Staikouras at the open event, accompanied by the deputy minister responsible for infrastructure, Nikos Tachiaos, the secretary of New Democracy’s parliamentary group Stavros Kalafatis, and VP & CEO of Elliniko Metro SA Nikos Kouretas.

Comprehensive plan for the improvement of public transportation in Thessaloniki

At the time, AMNA reported that the minister was given a tour of the works and saw the project’s progress. He also spoke with dozens of visitors who flocked to see the premises despite the rain, and they asked him questions about it.

“We are very near the completion of our target,” Staikouras stated. “This means that the justifiable doubt [among residents] about the timely completion of the projects is dropping. As political leaders, we are committed that all projects in Thessaloniki we will be on time.”

Greek Wine From Santorini Voted World’s Best

0
vineyard grapes wine
Vineyard. Credit: flickr / michael clarke stuff CC BY-SA 2.0

A Greek wine from Santorini has been listed as the top wine in the world on food and beverage-ranking website TasteAtlas.

Other varieties of Greek wine have been included in a TasteAtlas list of the top 100 drinks and beverages from around the world. Among these are wines from France, Italy, Chile, and Argentina.

Greek wines listed on TasteAtlas

The Vinsanto of Santorini

The first Greek wine on the list is the Vinsanto, which comes in first place overall. As the TasteAtlas article states, it is a dessert wine from Santorini, made with dried Assyrtiko and Aidani grapes.

Although the wine is similarly named, this Greek bottle has little in common with the better-known Vin Santo from Tuscany. The grapes are dried for around fourteen days and then fermented and ripened.

To achieve its full-bodied flavor, this wine must be aged in oak barrels for a minimum of two years, though most producers choose to age it for longer. The result is a sweet and dense wine that is full of flavor and rich in aromas. Both grape varieties are white-skinned, but the Vinsanto takes on a luscious golden color, which typically turns darker as the drink ages.

TasteAtlas reports that the wine is honeyed, sweet, and full-bodied, with aromas redolent of figs, raisins, apricots, caramel, nuts, and sweet spices, and that despite the concentrated flavors and dense texture, Vinsanto manages to remain balanced, maintaining acidity and freshness.

It is said that the wine should be served chilled, can be drunk on its own, and also pairs well with desserts and cheese.

The sour black wine of Naousa

Naousa wine.
Naousa wine. Credit: Martin Lopatka. CC BY 2.0/flickr

Listed in 25th place on TasteAtlas is the wine of Naousa. These are of the Xinomavro variety, native Greek wines that are often compared to Pinot Noir and Nebbiolo.

According to TasteAtlas, Naousa wine offers the perfect balance of tannins, sugars, and acidity, while aromas and flavors include a complex combination of savory notes often redolent of dark and red fruits, tomatoes, plums, earth, smoke, herbs, and spices.

Because of its complexity and finesse, Xinomavro is commonly cited as one of the best Greek wines. An ideal pairing for this tannic wine is game, lamb, tomato-based sauces, hearty stews, sausages, mushrooms, and aged cheese, according to TasteAtlas.

Malagousia

Sitting at number 39 is Malagousia, an ancient, white-skinned Greek grape that was saved from extinction by Vangelis Gerovassiliou, who brought it back from obscurity in the 1970s. The grape produces aromatic dry wines, which are usually of excellent quality.

“It is also used to make dense and perfumed dessert styles…the wines display intense aromas often reminiscent of peaches, pears, and tropical fruit, usually with citrusy, herbal, and subtle floral notes. On the palate, they are full-bodied, rich, and round, and the best examples manage to remain lively and fresh,” according to TasteAtlas.

Assyrtiko

Assyrtiko.
Assyrtiko. Credit: Agne27. CC BY 3.0/Wikimedia Commons/Agne27

At number 51 is Assyrtiko with a white grape variety indigenous to the island of Santorini. This can also be found on other Aegean islands, such as Paros. The soil of the island, which is rich in volcanic ash, appears to allow the grapes to retain their acidity regardless of how long they ripen. This gives these wines a long aging potential.

Agiorgitiko

Agiorgitiko.
Agiorgitiko. Credit: dullhunk. CC BY 2.0/flickr

Agiorgitiko is the most widely planted red grape variety in Greece. It is cultivated in lots of wine regions, but Nemea, where the grape originated, is its most significant region. Agiorgitiko is a versatile grape that can be vinified into several styles, and is often used as a backbone in many Greek blends.

Moschofilero

Moschofilero is a Greek grape that comes from Peloponnese. It is an aromatic and late-ripening variety that gives high yields but is sometimes sensitive and difficult to grow. Although it has a common presence, Moschofilero was only popularized in the 1970s and ’80s, primarily by the producers from PDO Mantinia, the most important wine region for Moschofilero.

Nemea

Located in the northeastern part of the Peloponnese, Nemea is a Greek appellation that produces varietal red wines from the native Agiorgitiko grapes. Despite the variety in style of the wines, from easy-drinking to rich and full-bodied, they typically display flavors and aromas redolent of red and black berries, plums, and prunes, while oak-aging tends to highlight spicy subtleties of nutmeg and black pepper.

In addition to the two Greek wines that made the list, TasteAtlas listed Greek coffees, as well as ouzo and tsikoudia, among the 100 best drinks in the world.

It is worth mentioning that number one on the list is Aguas Frescas from Mexico. This is a light non-alcoholic drink made from a combination of fruits, cucumbers, flowers, seeds, and grains. It is mixed with sugar and water.

TasteAtlas is an experiential travel online guide for traditional food that collates authentic recipes, food critic reviews, and research articles about popular ingredients and dishes. Describing itself as “a world atlas of traditional dishes, local ingredients, and authentic restaurants,” it features an interactive global food map with dish icons shown in their respective regions and purportedly contains nearly 10,000 dishes, drinks, and ingredients, as well as 9,000 restaurants.

The Unmatched Legacy of Ancient Greek Mathematician, Euclid

AI depiction of Euclid studying in ancient Athens.
AI depiction of a painting of Euclid, studying on a sunny evening in ancient Greece. Credit: DALLE via Perplexity for Greek Reporter

Euclid has been a monumental figure in the field of mathematics for centuries. His name echoes through time and history,  and he became one of the most recognizable mathematicians of ancient Greece.

Known primarily for his seminal work, The Elements, the contributions of Euclid in this manuscript formed the foundation of modern geometry.

His groundbreaking methods, as well as innovative scientific theories, continue to influence the way we understand shapes, spaces, and the very core of mathematical reasoning. Through his fundamentally influential work, Euclid has managed to become a foundational figure of mathematical education and thought across the globe.

The mystery of Euclid’s origins

Much of the life of Euclid remains unknown to modern-day scholars and is a mystery that remains to be solved by future archaeological evidence. Medieval sources from the Middle East provide much information about his life. However, the consensus is that they are all unverified and are, therefore, unreliable in forming a basic understanding of his life.

Hence, historical records provide very little accurate information of his actual origins. This has led experts to many disagreements regarding the whereabouts of his motherland. Nonetheless, it is believed Euclid was at the peak of his success around 300 BCE, most probably in Hellenistic Alexandria, Egypt. This was the time that the city was under the reign of Ptolemy I following Alexander the Great’s conquest of Egypt.

To distinguish him from an earlier philosopher by the same name, who was a student of Socrates and appeared in the dialogues of Plato, people often refer to him as “Euclid of Alexandria.”

The identity and personal life of Euclid are largely hypothetical and based on his contributions to mathematics rather than concrete documentation of his life. It has to be noted that, at that time, the name Euclid was very common among Greek men. This is something that makes the endeavor of unveiling the details of his early life even more challenging. Regardless, this enigmatic figure of the ancient Greek world may be distant in time but continues to spark curiosity and admiration to this day. Euclid will forever be known for his lasting impact on the world of mathematics.

The elements as Euclid’s blueprint for modern geometry

The manuscript The Elements stands as a monumental work in the history of mathematics. Structured as a total of thirteen books, it systematically explores issues such as geometry, proportion, and number theory.

Euclid’s structured and methodical approach, starting with axioms and building up to complex theorems through logical deductions, was revolutionary for its time. This work not only consolidated existing knowledge of the known world in these fields but also introduced Euclid’s own discoveries in areas such as geometry. It became, unintentionally so, a fundamental moment for science, as it managed to set the standard for mathematical proofs for future generations to follow.

The mathematical legacy of Euclid

The influence of the work of Euclid on mathematics cannot be exaggerated. The Elements became the textbook for teaching mathematics through the centuries. However, beyond geometry, one should never forget that Euclid contributed additional fields, as well. Optics, number theory, and even mechanics were among the numerous fields that Euclid worked on.

His study laid the foundational principles that would guide mathematicians into new discoveries and realizations for generations. This is what distinguished Euclid from other mathematicians so profoundly. His contributions became the definition of work with a timeless legacy that lasts to this day.

Euclid's Elements of geometry.
Euclid’s Elements of geometry, published in London in 1661. Credit: University of Glasgow Library, Flickr, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0

The impact on education and philosophy

The scientific methodology that Euclid used during his lifetime had a profound impact on the philosophy of mathematics and education as a whole. His logical structure that was used to prove theories, along with the rigorous proof-based approach he implemented, became a model for intellectual inquiry, reshaping scientific thought forever.

The Elements, for example, was not just a textbook on geometry used by students around the world. It was a manifesto on the power of logical reasoning. It had a lasting influence on educational systems and provoked philosophical thought far beyond his own time.

Controversies surrounding the work and existence of Euclid

Despite his monumental contributions that are almost unanimously acknowledged, some aspects of Euclid’s work have sparked scientific debates, too. Questions about who actually wrote The Elements have been common in the scholarly world and continue to cause controversy. There are even people who challenge his very existence. These scholars wonder whether Euclid was a single historical figure or potentially a composite of several mathematicians, whose groundbreaking work became known during our time under the name “Euclid.”

No matter the truth, these debates point to the significance of Euclid’s work in the development of mathematics as we know it today.

Dark-toned painting of Euclid holding open pages of a book with geometric diagrams.
Euclid presenting his geometric findings, as depicted in a classical painting. Credit: Jusepe de Ribera, J. Paul Getty Museum, Wikimedia Commons, Public Domain

From ancient Greece to the modern world

The profound and groundbreaking legacy of Euclid is proof of the timeless and limitless power of systematic thought and logical deduction in today’s scientific world. His work, especially The Elements, has shaped the field of mathematics in many profound ways. This will not change regardless of who Euclid was and where he resided. His innovative thinking influenced not only the subject of geometry itself but also the methods by which we understand and teach it to children and adults alike.

Euclid, alongside Archimedes and Apollonius of Perga, is considered among the most prominent mathematicians of ancient times. The three of them are also widely recognized for their profound impact on mathematics. However, the contributions of Euclid himself are so significant that modern geometry is often termed “Euclidean geometry” to differentiate it from the non-Euclidean geometries that emerged in the early nineteenth century in various places.

The legacy of Euclid even extends beyond mathematics. It has served as inspiration in the naming of various entities throughout the decades. These include the Euclid spacecraft of the European Space Agency (ESA), the lunar crater Euclides, and the minor planet 4354 Euclides.

To conclude, it is safe to say that despite the centuries that have passed since his actual lifetime, Euclid remains a crucial figure in the world of science. He symbolizes our common desire for knowledge of the past and the importance of using this in the advancement of future scientific understanding.

Related: Mathematics in Ancient Greece and Its Influence on Modern Science

Former Us Navy Admiral Plans Search for Alien Life Underwater

0
Former US Navy Admiral plans to send remote vehicle down to seabed to identify potential alien USO.
Former US Navy Admiral plans to send remote vehicle down to seabed to identify potential alien USO. Credit: tj.blackwell. CC BY 2.0/flickr

Extra-terrestrial life has been a huge source of awe and mystery for human beings, particularly in recent years. Even NASA launched a probe to find out what unidentified flying objects are out there. However, the search has now switched from the sky to the sea with certain former US military personnel hoping to discover clues to alien life.

The former head of the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) is launching a probe into unidentified alien submersible objects (USOs) and, in particular, an unusual anomaly spotted on the seabed off the coast of California.

Timothy Gallaudet, previously a rear admiral in the US Navy, has spent the last year and a half interviewing numerous sailors, submariners, military personnel, and members of the US Coastguard. They all claim to have seen unidentified—possibly alien—vessels in the water.

One particular sighting was filmed by the USS Omaha off the coast of San Diego in southern California in 2019. A shadowy object was seen moving rapidly before splashing down into the water. In the well-known Tic Tac incident of 2004, US Navy pilots described an oblong vessel, shaped like the breath mint, hovering just above the water off the California coast.

Sonar has shown a strange trench on the seafloor which looks as if an object has crashed into a ridge and subsequently skidded to a stop. Gallaudet is planning to send a remote-controlled submarine to the site to see if there are any signs of what caused the phenomena.

“I cannot explain this feature and therefore want to use a ROV (remotely operated underwater vehicle) to dive from a ship and capture video of it,” he told The Telegraph.
“That may allow us to identify its detailed characteristics and potentially determine what caused it. No one has agreed to provide a ship or ROV yet. A hypothesis is that it may have been formed by an interaction of an UAP (unidentified aerial phenomena) or USO with the seabed.”

Are there aliens in the waters around the US and elsewhere?

The former US Navy Rear Admiral argues that evidence for alien USOs could be present in the US Navy’s acoustic data, which is currently classified. “I have not seen signatures on such data, but I have spoken to one former submarine officer who has,” he added.

This week, Gallaudet released a report looking into the phenomenon with the Sol Foundation, a consortium of academics, military, and government officials dedicated to researching UFOs. The group is calling for investigation into USOs to be made a national ocean research priority for the US government. It claims that the underwater anomalies are a potential threat to maritime security.

The report centers in on an incident in Aguadilla, Puerto Rico, where a thermal imaging system on a US Customs and Border Protection aircraft detected a fast-moving vessel which entered the Atlantic Ocean.

Speaking at a recent Sol Foundation symposium, Gallaudet said:

“Just in the year-and-a-half or so now that I’ve become active and started interviewing people I have met, dozens of people, commercial, military, Coast Guard, mariners and submariners who have had observations. I don’t have any data yet. That’s the next step. But this is several dozen people that have seen phenomena in our oceans, the tropical eastern and western Pacific, the Gulf of Mexico, the Caribbean, Mediterranean, and the Indian Ocean, and the North Atlantic and eastern seaboard. So this is happening, and I am trying to get a better understanding of it.”

Insurance in Ancient Greece: A Pioneer in Mitigating Risks

Insurance Ancient Greece
Ancient Greek society had in place some basic forms of risk-sharing and financial protection predominantly within maritime contracts. Credit: , CC BY-NC-SA 2.0

The history of Insurance goes back to ancient Greece as people at the time employed insurance-like practices in certain domains, predominantly within maritime contracts.

Although Insurance, as we understand it today, did not exist in the form of modern insurance companies or policies, ancient Greek society had in place some basic forms of risk-sharing and financial protection.

Many ancient Greek states were maritime powers depending on sea trade. But, it was a dangerous trade and carried inherent risks, such as shipwrecks, piracy, and unpredictable weather conditions.

So, a financial arrangement called “bottomry,” was used. It wasn’t exactly insurance. According to Solomon Huebner in his scholarly article in The Annuals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science:

“…The commercial nations of the ancient world secured the benefits of insurance through the so-called ‘loans on bottomry,’…loans made on the security of the ship and cargo at high rates of interest, and with the understanding that the principal with interest was to be repaid only in the event of the safe arrival of the vessel…”

As Historian Erik Brown writes in Lessons from History, bottomry was like some odd mixture of a loan and insurance. Lenders gave you money. But you only repaid it with the interest required if your ship made it to the destination and back. So if the ship sank, the lender absorbed the loss.

Insurance and maritime law in ancient Greece

Another example of an Insurance-like mechanism in ancient Greece was the “loans on respondentia” which allowed loans to be secured using the cargo itself. These contracts demonstrated attempts to distribute risks among multiple parties, thus embodying the fundamental principle of insurance.

Ancient Rhodes, a supreme naval power, developed rules of law to deal with shipping disputes, including a code of maritime law known as “Lex Rhodia”, believed to have been written around 900 – 800 BC. Whilst no copy of “Lex Rhodia” has ever been found, it is mentioned in later Roman writings.

As the history site Radar notes the law is explicitly mentioned in a book of Roman law text, “Opinions of Julius Paulus” (235 AD):

“It is provided by the Lex Rhodia that if merchandise is thrown overboard for the purpose of lightening a ship, the loss is made good by the assessment of all which is made for the benefit of all.

“If after a ship has been lightened by throwing the merchandise overboard, it should be lost, and the merchandise of others should be recovered by divers, it has been settled that he who threw his property overboard for the purpose of saving the ship will be entitled to an account of the same.

“Where either the ship – or a mast – is lost in a storm, the passengers are not liable to contribution, unless the vessel was saved through the passengers themselves cutting down the mast to insure their own preservation.

“Where, for the purpose of lightening a ship, merchandise is thrown into a boat and lost, it is established that the loss shall be made good by the assessment of the property which remained safe in the ship. If, however, the ship should be lost, no account should be taken of the boat which was saved, or of the merchandise it may have contained.

“Contribution by assessment should be made where property has been thrown into the sea, and the ship has been saved.”

Temples act as Insurance in ancient Greece

Religion played a significant role in Ancient Greek society, permeating various aspects of life. Temples, in particular, acted as centers of communal activities, including the management of financial risks.

Temples often housed the wealth of the community and were considered safe havens in times of crisis or disaster.

Individuals and maritime traders would deposit money, offerings, or loans at these temples, providing a form of protection against potential losses. While not precisely insurance in its modern sense, these practices exhibited a collective effort to handle financial uncertainties within the bounds of religious institutions.

In ancient Greece, especially in Athens, there were various forms of mutual aid societies or clubs called “eranoi” or “thiasoi.” These groups were formed by individuals with common interests or occupations, and they contributed to a common fund from which members could draw in times of need.

While not insurance in the modern sense, they provided a form of collective support during times of financial hardship.

Menander, the Greek King of India

 

Menander Soter, Greek king of India
Greek king of India Menander I Soter. Credits: CNG Coins / Wikipedia CC BY-SA 3.0

King Menander began as a Greek general of King Demetrius of the Euthydemid dynasty. He is considered as probably the most successful Greek king of India, and ruled a huge empire from Gandhara to the Hindu holy city of Mathura. But lets start at the beginning!

Euthydemid Dynasty

As per W. W. Tarn in his book ‘Greeks in Bactria and India’, to omit the Euthydemid dynasty from Hellenistic (Greek) history, as has usually been done, and to confine that history to the four dynasties which bordered on the Mediterranean one, throws that history out of balance. Therefore it is important to learn about the Euthydemids. Diodotus, the Greek governor of Bactria, was the first to rebel against Antiochus, the Greek king of the Seleucid dynasty, and later on another satrap, Euthydemus defeated Diodotus’ son and founded the Euthydemid dynasty.

Menander was originally a Greek general of Euthydemid King Demetrius. He is considered as probably the most successful Indo-Greek king, and ruled a huge empire from Gandhara to the Hindu holy city of Mathura. He conquered Pataliputra (called Palibothra by Greeks), a city once ruled by the great Indian emperor Asoka, something that even Alexander the Great could not do. Menander later left Pataliputra and formed his frontier south of Mathura.

The Milinda-panha, a Buddhist text, purports to record a dialogue between Buddhist sage Nagasena and king Menander. This text is regarded as canonical in Burmese Buddhism, and included as part of the book of Khuddaka Nikaya.

From General to Emperor

So how did a general of the Euthydemids became an emperor? The answer, as per W. W. Tarn, is that he was voted in by the Euthydemid army after the death of Demetrius, and legitimized his rule by marrying Demetrius’ daughter Agathocleia.  

Menander ruled from his capital Sagala, modern Sialkot in Pakistan. He also had a summer capital in the hills, and made military settlements of troops in the west, such as Daedala in India, an Indo-Cretan city settled by Cretan mercenaries and possibly Lycians (as per W. W. Tarn), and Salagissa, somewhere east of the Sutlej river, a military settlement of Pisidian mercenaries (from Pisidia, an ancient region of southern Asia Minor). 

Menander I Soter Drachm Coin
Menander I Soter depicted on Drachm Coin. Credit: ancientcointraders /Wikimedia Commons / cc by 4.0

As far as Menander’s coins are concerned, he had silver Drachms which depicted goddess Athena striding and hurling a thunderbolt. As per John Keay, in his book ‘India: A History’, the Menander depicted on his coins does not have the look of a conqueror. His topi-style helmet appears much too big; protruding curls and delicate features suggest effeminacy; and he calls himself ‘Basileos’ and ‘Soter’, ‘King’ and ‘Saviour’, rather then ‘Conqueror’ or ‘Patriot’. His other legacy is more in keeping with this gentler image, for in Buddhist tradition he is remembered as ‘Milinda.’

Chakravartin

greco-buddhism greece ancient buddhism
A seated Gandhara Buddha from 300-500 AD that is the epitome of Greco-Buddhism. Credit: Willard84/Wikimedia Commons/CC BY-SA 4.0

Menander was a great benefactor of the Buddhist faith. As per the text Milindpanha, Menander not only converted to Buddhism, he became an Arhat, which in Buddhism means one who has attained the goal of enlightenment or awakening (bodhi). The difference between an Arhat and a Buddha is that the Buddha attains enlightenment by himself, whereas the Arhat does it by following the teachings of another.

An Indo-Chinese tradition, connects Menander with the origin of the most famous statue of Buddha in Indo-China, the statue the Emerald Buddha, which Menander’s teacher Nagasena made out of a magic emerald by supernatural power. As per Plutarch, after Menander’s death the cities raised stupas (Buddhist temples) over his ashes. In Buddhist literature four kinds of men, and they only, are described as worthy of stupas: Buddhas, Pratyeka Buddhas (solitary saints), disciples of a Buddha who have become saints, and kings who are Chakravartins (the ancient Indian conception of the world ruler). Plutarch mentions that Menander was honored because he was a Chakravartin.

The Buddha

Long, long ago, prince Siddhartha Gautama, who later became the Buddha, meaning the “enlighted one”, was born in Lumbini in the present day nation state of Nepal. Though Siddhartha was born in Nepal, it was in India that Buddhism was born.

Over the years the message of Gautama Buddha spread far and wide; in fact long before Islam emerged, Buddhism provided a form of religious cohesion along the Silk Road route that connected Asia to Europe.

Victor of Palibothra

Alexander the Great
Statue of Alexander the Great in Thessaloniki. Credit: Alexander Gale / Greek Reporter

Though a benefactor of a pacifist religion, Menander was still a military conqueror, and achieved what Alexander the Great could not achieve, the conquest of Pataliputra (Greek: Palibothra). Parts of Bihar state in India, namely Patna, Gaya and parts of Shahabad were known as Magadha in ancient times. Magadha, where Gautama Buddha attained enlightenment, was a military super power ruled by Nanda King Xandrames (Dhanananda) during the time of Alexander the Great’s invasion. Xandrames’ army was believed to have over 20,000 cavalry, 200,000 infantry, 2,000 chariots, and 3,000 elephants.

This army was so powerful that the Greek army of Macedonia, which had defeated emperor Darius III of Persia, feared the might and control of this Indian opponent; they strongly opposed any forward invasion by Alexander the Great after winning the battle of Hydaspes, and wanted to return to Persia as soon as possible.  

Alexander could not conquer the capital of Magadha Pataliputra and began his homeward journey in 325 BC and in 324 BC; he died in Persia. However his aim was fulfilled by Menander who, as per Irish historian V. A. Smith and W. W. Tarn, conquered the city, the capital of Magadha, and achieved what Alexander the Great could not achieve. He came to be considered as probably the most successful Greek king of India, a king respected by Buddhists all around the world. Many Indians still name their sons Milind, after Menander.

The Greatest Byzantine Greek Scholars of the Renaissance

Renaissance scholars
Scholars of the Renaissance, including the Greek academic Demetrios Chalkondyles (pictured far right). Credit: Domenico Ghirlandaio / Public domain / Wikimedia Commons

Between the 14th and 15th centuries, a wave of Greek scholars left their beleaguered homeland in the Byzantine Empire for the Italian Peninsula, where their work would play an important role in the flowering of the Renaissance.

The Renaissance, which literally means “rebirth”, was a period usually identified as lasting between the 14th and 17th centuries. It was characterized by an increased interest in the Greek and Roman past, with the scholars of the time looking back to Classical civilization for inspiration in the arts and sciences.

When the Byzantine Greek scholars arrived in Italy, they brought centuries of knowledge from Greco-Roman civilization with them. Medieval Italian scholars had already taken an interest in Classical Roman civilization, but this new wave of Byzantine intellectuals were well versed in ancient Greek sources and greatly widened the scope of the academic and artistic endeavors that were then possible.

The Byzantine Greek contribution to the Renaissance

The Byzantine Empire is often overlooked for its contributions to philosophy, science, and the arts, but without the influence of this enigmatic civilization, the Renaissance would not have achieved the heights of human achievement it has since become renowned for.

As Byzantine power waned and eventually collapsed entirely under the stress of the Ottoman invasions, many of its best and brightest thinkers left for safer shores. The majority of these Byzantine Greek scholars arrived in Italy, where they would make important contributions during the Renaissance period.

The influence of these scholars was diverse and wide ranging, especially as far as the transfer of ancient Greek knowledge to a larger European audience was concerned.

For example, Leonardo Bruni, the preeminent humanist philosopher and historian of his time, was influenced by the philosophy of Aristotle and Plato, whereas the brilliant Leonardo da Vinci drew inspiration from ancient Greek medical practitioners like Galen for his anatomical studies.

Manuel Chrysoloras (c. 1350 – 1415)

Manuel Chrysoloras was an influential Byzantine Greek teacher and diplomat, and a personal friend of the Byzantine emperor Manuel II Palaiologos. He first visited Italy during the 1390s as a diplomat to win over Western military support against the Ottoman Empire.

However, in 1397, he left Constantinople again to take up a new position as a professor in Florence at the behest of Coluccio Salutati, the most prominent political figure in the city until the rise of the Medici.

Chrysoloras was widely celebrated by his Italian peers for bringing Greek scholarship to Italy. In fact, the aforementioned Leonardo Bruni made the exaggerated claim that he had brought back the study of Greek to Italy for the first time in seven centuries.

His most important works were a Comparison of the Old and New Rome, wherein he compared Constantinople and Rome, and a Greek grammar textbook titled Erotemata (Questions).

Chrysoloras counted many prominent names among his pupils, including Poggio Bracciolini, Leonardo Bruni, Guarino da Verona, Carlo Marsuppini, Niccolò Niccoli, Palla Strozzi, and Pier Paolo Vergerio the Elder.

Manuel Chrysoloras
Portrait of Manuel Chrysoloras from the 17th century. Credit: Nicolas de Larmessin and Esme de Boulonois / Wikimedia Commons CC BY-SA 4.0

Georgios Gemistos Plethon (1344 – c. 1452)

Georgios Gemistos Plethon was one of the foremost Greek scholars of the late Byzantine period and is most renowned for reintroducing Plato’s ideas to Italy and Western Europe. In fact, he adopted the surname of Plethon as a deliberate homage to Plato.

Plethon spent most of his life in Mystra in the Despotate of Morea in the southern Peloponnese, where he had been sent by the Byzantine Emperor Manuel II Palaiologos. However, Plethon spent a brief but influential time as a tutor in Italy, where he had the chance to introduce his pupils to the most important thinkers of antiquity.

In 1438, Byzantine Emperor John VIII Palaiologos invited Plethon to attend the Council of Ferrara – later known as the Council of Florence – to discuss the unification of the Greek and Latin Churches. A number of his students joined him at the council, including Bessarion, Gennadius Scholarius, and Mark Eugenikos.

Just one year later, Plethon was invited by a group of Florentine humanists to teach in their city. During his time in Florence, he delivered lectures on Platonic teachings and wrote the volume Wherein Aristotle disagrees with Plato, during a bout of sickness.

The Greek scholar only taught in Florence between 1439 and 1440 but his impact on the developing Renaissance was profound. He helped popularize the study of Plato in Italy whereas before only Aristotle had been relatively well known.

The immensely powerful Florentine banker and politician Cosimo de’ Medici may even have been inspired to found and patronize the Accademia Platonica after attending Plethon’s lectures.

Plethon died in either 1452 or 1454, so it is not known whether he would have been alive to hear of the fall of Constantinople in 1453. In any case, his reputation endured after his death to such an extent that even his remains were sought after. During a military campaign in the Peloponnese between 1464 and 1466, Sigismondo Pandolfo Malatesta, one of the greatest generals of the Italian Renaissance, stole the remains of the Greek scholar and brought them back to Italy, where he interred them at the Tempio Malatestiano in Rimini.

Georgios Gemistos Plethon

Portrait of Georgios Gemistos Plethon, detail of a fresco by acquaintance Benozzo Gozzoli, Palazzo Medici Riccardi, Florence, Italy. Credit: Benozzo Gozzoli / Public domain / Wikimedia Commons

Theodorus Gaza (1398 – c. 1478)

Theodorus Gaza was one of the most prolific Greek professors active in Italy during the Renaissance. He was originally from Thessaloniki but fled to Italy in 1430 after the city’s final fall to the Ottoman Turks.

He was appointed as a professor of Greek at the recently established University of Ferrara in 1447. His reputation as an outstanding teacher attracted a large number of students from various parts of Italy. Among his pupils in Ferrara was Rodolphus Agricola.

Unlike Plethon, who venerated the teachings of Plato, Gaza favored the works of Aristotle, and contributed immensely to the philosophical defense of Aristotelianism during the debates of the 15th century.

In 1450, he was invited by Pope Nicholas V to translate the works of Aristotle, Theophrastus, and other ancient scholars from Greek into Latin.

After the death of Nicholas V, Gaza relocated to Naples where he enjoyed the patronage of King Alfonso the Magnanimous between 1456 to 1458. He spent the remainder of his years living in Calabria and was buried in the Basilian monastery of San Giovanni a Piro around the years 1477 or 1478.

After his death, the Italian Renaissance scholar Ermolao Barbaro wrote a letter to Pope Sixtus IV in praise of his Greek contemporary.

“That Greek man outdid all Latins in the task of writing and translating. If he had lived longer, he would have enriched the Latin language in this field as well. He did that indeed in those most perfect books of Aristotle’s On Animals and Theophrastus’ On Plants. In my view, he is the only one to challenge antiquity itself.”

Theodorus Gaza
Portrait of Theodorus Gaza. Credit: I, Sailko, / Wikimedia commons CC BY-SA 3.0

Ioannis Argyropoulos (1415 – 1487)

Ioannis (John) Argyropoulos was another great Greek scholar, lecturer, and humanist philosopher during the Renaissance. Like Plethon and other notable Byzantine scholars of the time, he attended the Council of Florence.

Argyropoulos studied Theology and Philosophy in Constantinople where he would also teach for a time after completing his studies. One of his pupils, Constantine Lascaris, would also one day teach in Italy and contribute to the Greek revival of the Renaissance.

After the fall of Constantinople in 1453 Argyropoulos fled to the Peloponnese, before relocating again to Italy in 1456. He had already received a a Doctor of Theology degree from the University of Padua during previous travels to Italy years before the fall of the Byzantine capital.

Argyropoulos soon found a scholarly position in Italy and was made the head of the Greek department at Florence’s Florentine Studium. In 1471 however, the city of Florence was gripped in the deadly clutches of the plague, and he decided to move again to Rome where he continued to teach until his death.

The most famous pupil of Argyropoulos was the famed polymath Leonardo da Vinci. He also taught the influential Florentine statesmen and bankers Pietro de’ Medici and Lorenzo de’ Medici; the Italian classical scholar and poet Angelo Poliziano; the German humansit and scholar Johann Reuchlin; and Jacques Lefèvre d’Étaples, a French humanist and theologian.

John Argyropoulos
Portrait of John Argyropoulos. Credit: Nicolas de Larmessin / Esme de Boulonois / Wikimedia Commons CC BY-SA 4.0

Demetrios Chalkokondyles (1423 – 1511)

Demetrios Chalkokondyles taught Greek literature prolifically at the most renowned universities of Renaissance Italy, including Padua, Florence, and Milan. He was originally from Athens and lived for a time in the Peloponnese before permanently relocating to Italy in 1447.

He arrived in Rome in 1449 and was tutored by his fellow Greek scholar Theodorus Gaza. A while later Chalkokondyles impressed Lorenzo de’ Medici with his ability to bring Greek Classical literature alive and was appointed to teach Medici’s sons.

In 1463, Chalkokondyles became a professor at Padua before taking over from John Argyropoulos as the head of the Greek Literature department in Florence in 1479. It was during his tenure at Florence that he completed his most important work, an edited edition of Homer’s work.

Chalkokondyles was the first person to publish printed editions of the works of Homer, Isocrates, and the Suda Lexicon. The printing press had been invented in the 1430s in Germany, finally arriving in Italy in 1465. Chalkokondyles published the first printed edition of Homer’s work in 1488.

He was pained greatly by the fall of Constantinople and was an outspoken campaigner for the liberation of his native Greece from the Ottoman Turks. In the decades after the fall of the Byzantine capital, Chalkokondyles tried to rally support from Venice and the other Italian centers of power for a counter invasion to expel the Ottomans from his homeland.

Despite marrying at the late age of 61 in 1484, Chalkokondyles sired 10 children over the course of his marriage. He spent his final years tutoring in Milan after being invited there by Duke Ludovico Sforza.

Demetrios Chalkokondyles
Portrait of Demetrios Chalkokondyles. Credit: Nicolas de Larmessin / Esme de Boulonois / Wikimedia Commons CC BY-SA 4.0