GreekReporter.comSocietyCrimeSusan Logothetti, the Detective Who Cracked Two 40-Year-Old Murders With a Chewing-Gum...

Susan Logothetti, the Detective Who Cracked Two 40-Year-Old Murders With a Chewing-Gum Sting

const scriptEl = document.createElement('script'); scriptEl.setAttribute('fetchpriority', 'high'); scriptEl.setAttribute('charset', 'UTF-8'); const scriptURL = new URL('https://trinitymedia.ai/player/trinity/2900024068/?'); scriptURL.searchParams.set('pageURL', window.location.href); scriptEl.src = scriptURL.toString(); document.currentScript.parentNode.insertBefore(scriptEl, document.currentScript);
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
Chewing gum provided the fresh DNA sample investigators sought in the cold-case investigation.
Chewing gum provided the fresh DNA sample investigators sought in the cold-case investigation by Susan Logothetti. Credit: Everett Police Department

A staged chewing-gum survey helped an Everett cold-case detective obtain DNA evidence that ultimately resolved two murders from the 1980s.

Detective Susan Logothetti helped solve two long-unsolved murders in Everett, Washington, after posing as a market researcher to obtain a fresh DNA sample from Mitchell Gaff. Gaff later admitted killing Judy Weaver and Susan Vesey and received a sentence of at least 50 years and up to life in prison on May 13, 2026.

From social services to cold-case investigations

Logothetti, an Illinois native, worked with abused children at a foster-care agency and later served as a probation officer. She joined the Everett Police Department in 2012 and became a sex-crimes detective in 2019.

Her interest in unresolved homicides grew as the department’s previous cold-case investigator approached retirement. Logothetti asked to assume that work and took responsibility for cold-case homicide investigations in 2022.

A decades-old murder and a DNA match

One of those cases was the killing of Judy Weaver. Firefighters discovered Weaver’s body in her Everett home on June 2, 1984, while responding to a fire. The crime remained unsolved for almost four decades.

Fresh forensic analysis produced a significant lead in November 2023. A DNA profile developed from evidence in the case matched Gaff through CODIS, the national law-enforcement DNA database. Investigators still needed a new sample from him to verify the result.

Susan Logothetti's portrait from the Everett Police Department.
Susan Logothetti’s portrait from the Everett Police Department.

Attempts to recover an item discarded by Gaff proved unsuccessful, so Logothetti and two colleagues devised another approach. Wearing lime-green shirts marked with a fictional “Zolt Energy Gum” logo, they approached him as consumer researchers and invited him to evaluate different gum flavors.

Gaff took part and placed each used piece of gum into a small dish as he moved through the samples. Investigators recovered the gum and tested the DNA on it. The result linked him to evidence from Weaver’s murder.

Police arrested Gaff in May 2024, nearly 40 years after Weaver was killed.

A second Everett murder

The investigation later expanded to the death of Susan Vesey, who was found murdered by her husband on July 12, 1980, the morning after her 21st birthday.

Vesey’s husband, Ken, contacted police years later about the unresolved case. Logothetti identified similarities between the two killings and arranged for preserved evidence to undergo new testing. DNA recovered from a cord connected Gaff to Vesey’s murder.

Prosecutors charged Gaff in the Vesey case on March 13, 2026. He pleaded guilty on April 16 to two counts of first-degree murder. Police said he acknowledged both killings in court and provided information that aligned with evidence gathered during the investigations.

Another cold-case arrest

Logothetti has also investigated the killing of Mary Ann Daniels, a 33-year-old woman found dead in her Everett home on February 1, 1989.

Working with police in Las Vegas, Logothetti helped arrest Joseph Andrew Jacquez on January 25, 2025, in connection with Daniels’ death. Everett police said forensic genetic genealogy led investigators to Jacquez and that DNA found on the instrument used in the killing matched him.

Those claims describe the police case against Jacquez and do not establish a conviction. A later court outcome could not be independently confirmed.

Then-Everett Police Chief John DeRousse credited Logothetti’s persistence in pursuing the Daniels investigation nearly 36 years after the crime.

Her role in the Gaff case continued through the final moments of the prosecution. After his sentencing, Logothetti handcuffed him and accompanied correctional officers as they took him back to jail—more than two years after the staged gum survey secured the DNA sample investigators had sought.

See all the latest news from Greece and the world at Greekreporter.com. Contact our newsroom to report an update or send your story, photos and videos. Follow GR on Google News and subscribe here to our daily email!



National Hellenic Museum

More greek news and world updates